History to the Defeated
  • Home
  • Introduction
  • Auden and "Spain"
  • The Cast (In Order of Appearance)
  • Slaves: Spartacus
  • Angelcynn: Harold II
  • Cathars: Béatrice de Planissoles
  • Peasants: John Ball
  • Catholics: Robert Catesby
  • Levellers: Freeborn John
  • Luddites: Ned Ludd
  • Communards: Louis Banqui
  • Communists: John Cornford
  • Fascists: Oswald Mosley
  • Weather: Joe and Rose
  • Baader-Meinhof: Ulrike
Picture
Spartacus
Picture
Harold II
Picture
Béatrice de Planissoles
Picture
John Ball
Picture
John Lilburne
Picture
Ned Ludd
Picture
Louis Blanqui
Picture
John Cornford
Picture
Bill Ayers and Bernadine Dohrn
Picture
Ulrike Meinhof
“We were the people who were not in the papers. We lived
in the blank white spaces on the edges of print.”
Margaret Atwood
'The Handmaid's Tale', 1985

For every victory there is a defeat, and History is littered with them on both sides of the political divide. More often than not, it is the Left (in its most general sense) that loses out. There is even a phrase for it, Walter Benjamin's "Left melancholia", to describe resignation to the inevitable defeat of the oppressed by the oppressor​. But the subjects discussed here have not been chosen because they are of the Left. In some cases, the term is meaningless. In others, it is the status quo which is defeated. And the choices are, in any case, based on very personal criteria. 
 
I wanted a broad spectrum of historical time, so the subjects of this project were born in different eras: from the first century BCE to the 20th century.

I wanted them to be motivated by different needs and ambitions, so these are driven by religion, politics, desperation; sometimes all three.

I wanted them to come from different classes, so we have a variety of backgrounds, from slaves to bourgeoisie, from clerics to kings, from poets to philosophers.

And I wanted them to be different, to be representative primarily of themselves. (The exceptions to this are the adjacent chapters on the Weather Underground and the Baader-Meinhof Group, but although the parallels are pronounced, there is sufficient difference between them to justify individual inclusion.)

Ultimately, of course, they must all have failed in their objectives, to be a lost cause, to have been defeated. 
 
And history to the defeated
May say Alas but cannot help or pardon.

Each of the following titles is a link (which may be a quicker form of navigation than the contents header). They are, in order of appearance:
 
Spartacus and the Third Servile War
 
Harold and the Anglo-Saxons
 
Béatrice de Plannissoles and the Cathars
 
John Ball and the Pesantry

Robert Catesby and the Gunpowder Plot
 
John Lilburne and the Levellers
 
Ned Ludd and the Luddites
 
Louis Blanqui and the Paris Commune
 
John Cornford and the Spanish Civil War

Oswald Mosley and the British Union of Fascists
​
Bernadine Dohrn and the Weather Underground
 
Ulrike Meinhof and the Red Army Fraction

Vertical Divider
  • Home
  • Introduction
  • Auden and "Spain"
  • The Cast (In Order of Appearance)
  • Slaves: Spartacus
  • Angelcynn: Harold II
  • Cathars: Béatrice de Planissoles
  • Peasants: John Ball
  • Catholics: Robert Catesby
  • Levellers: Freeborn John
  • Luddites: Ned Ludd
  • Communards: Louis Banqui
  • Communists: John Cornford
  • Fascists: Oswald Mosley
  • Weather: Joe and Rose
  • Baader-Meinhof: Ulrike